Count of Monte Cristo–Fiction and Non-fiction

alexandre-dumas-the-count-of-monte-cristo-1405396754k4ng8My first mistake was trying to listen to The Count of Monte Cristo on 2x speed as an audio book.  That was a little nuts, especially with all of the French place names and characters, so at times the kids would ask in confusion, “What language is this story in?”  Plus the audio book was like 79 hours long or something.

Life is too short.

Since I read far faster than I listen, I got the hard copy book from the library.  To my chagrin, after about a month and a half of listening, it turned out I was only halfway through. I toyed with giving it up, but decided that after so much investment I was going to finish this book, by George.

OK, the book is a classic. It’s not poorly written, just insanely long, and incredibly indulgent. Imagine you’ve been wronged, and then you have all the money in the world and could spend a decade getting back at everyone. Would you do it? I, for one, would not (see Romans 12:19). But if you were to concoct a revenge fantasy, The Count of Monte Cristo would make a good handbook.

black countWhat really helped me understand the novel and push through to the end was reading Tom Reiss’s informative non-fiction work on Dumas’s father, The Black Count. It turns out that Dumas based the count on his own father’s story. The Black Count tells the story of the senior Dumas, including a fascinating history of race relations in France, the tricky political situations facing military officers in the revolutionary and Napoleonic periods, and Dumas’s incredible and misunderstood career. I’m grateful to my friend Sheila at The Deliberate Reader (link is to her link-up post for this book so you can get other perspectives!) for recommending the books together!

I’m glad I read these books, although I wouldn’t say this was a favorite classic for me. If you’re planning to read The Count of Monte Cristo, I highly recommend that you read The Black Count first or concurrently. It will really deepen your understanding and help you get through the interminable bits of the novel.


Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links.

3 thoughts on “Count of Monte Cristo–Fiction and Non-fiction

  1. Catherine, I’m glad that you wrote about this. I am wanting to read The Mount of Monte Cristo this year since I’ve never read it. Ryan has read it 3x and loves it! But…I’m in a funk with reading and the Black Count sounds much more interesting! I’ll read that first and then tackle The Count of Monte Cristo.

    Been thinking of you a lot lately. I would love to get together. I’m just very pregnant and then we’re moving to VA, but I’d love for it to work out somehow!

    1. Even if you only read The Black Count, you’ll have lots to discuss with Ryan. Then, if you do tackle the novel, be sure to read it in written form! I wonder if I might have liked it more that way.

      It would be magnificent to get together before you move! You have a lot more on your plate than I do, so let me know if there are any days or times that would work and not be difficult or disruptive, and I will make it work!

  2. Hi Catherine! I’ve been reading the books with Sheila too! I enjoyed reading your perspective of the two books and I agree with your thought that the books should be read together or the non-fiction account before The Count of Monte Cristo. I really enjoyed The Count of Monte Cristo and while not my favorite genre, I found The Black Count interesting and eye opening in parts. I had no idea about some of the French history and was quite surprised by their views on race and their rather racy behavior!
    Mimi recently posted..What Love Is: Week 4 Recap

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

CommentLuv badge

A Spirited Mind HomeAboutReadingWritingParenting

Thank you for joining the conversation at A Spirited Mind! Please keep your comments kind and friendly, even if you're disagreeing with me or another commenter. Comments that use inappropriate language, or that are cruel, threatening, or violent will be deleted. I'm sure you understand!